Call Tracking and SEO: Harmful or Helpful?

Ashley Roth • August 14, 2018

All business owners share one thing in common -- a yearning for a more defined return on investment from their marketing and advertising efforts. In marketing circles, this is called "closing the loop." One of the most effective ways businesses can close the loop and gain a clearer picture on their return on investment is through call tracking.


What is Call Tracking?

Call tracking is the process of determining how callers found your business. If you're like most business owners, nothing is more frustrating than spending your hard-earned money on advertising and marketing efforts with nothing to show for it. Call tracking eliminates this everyday angst by identifying marketing channels that make your phone ring.

If you research call tracking and search engine optimization, the million dollar question everyone is trying to answer is whether call tracking is hurtful or helpful to your SEO. We answer this question below.


Reasons Call Tracking Can Hurt Your SEO

The primary place call tracking can be harmful is in your local SEO. Local SEO is a form of optimization that helps local businesses appear in relevant local searches. At BlinkJar, we like to say that Local SEO is the yellow pages of today, because the search queries are all centered around NAP - name, address, and phone number. NAP is the most critical ingredient in a local search strategy. Google reviews the name, address, and phone number of a business to ensure a consistent listing across all online directories. Any inconsistent, incomplete, or missing listings will hurt the chances of your business appearing in the local search results of Google. When you have consistent and accurate listings, your business becomes more trustworthy in the eyes of Google and the likelihood your business will show up in local search results is high.


NAP is why many experts feel call tracking can have a negative impact on local search rankings. If you are using various call tracking numbers across the web, it tends to confuse Google's algorithms and will hurt your local search rankings. Google looks at these inconsistent phone numbers as a red flag.


Using call tracking numbers in directory listings will hurt your SEO. A rather simple fix is not to use call tracking numbers in directory listings. One way to ensure you are using call tracking correctly is by using DNI: Dynamic Number Insertion. When applying DNI, a unique phone number displays, via Javascript, based on a source or a keyword. The good news is the default number is hard-coded and does not change which eliminates any risk of having various call tracking numbers pushed to local directory listings.


Reasons Call Tracking Can Help Your SEO

I just laid out one-way call tracking can have a negative impact on your SEO. On the flip side, there are many ways call tracking can help SEO. Let's take a look.


Call Tracking is a Content Map

Most call tracking software providers, like CallRail, have an option for recording calls. By listening to calls, you can gain a broader perspective on the common questions and roadblocks faced by your potential customers. You can then take these questions and answer them via website pages and blogs. Creating and implementing a content strategy for answering these common questions will have a positive impact on your SEO. 


Call Tracking Helps with Landing Page Optimization

If you know what search query or keyword was responsible for a landing page conversion, wouldn't that be helpful? Call tracking can pinpoint the keywords accountable for generating phone calls. Knowing this information can help you better optimize your landing pages for future searches, visits, and conversions.


Call Tracking Helps to Optimize Your Website by Location

Call tracking helps determine the location of the caller. If there is a trend of conversions from a specific geographic location, then you should center your landing pages and conversion efforts around this area.


Is Call Tracking Helpful or Harmful for SEO?

In short, call tracking is far more helpful than harmful to SEO. If you are a business owner who wants to gain a deeper understanding of your marketing and advertising efforts, implementing call tracking software will change your view of marketing and advertising for the better. If you're looking for someone to implement call tracking for you, we can help.


AEO is SEO
By Jared Broussard July 29, 2026
Is AEO replacing SEO? Learn why both rely on the same fundamentals to help businesses earn visibility, trust, and citations in AI search.
The fragmentation of search. Why Being Found Is No Longer Just About Google
By Rikki Broussard July 23, 2026
Your customers are still searching. They are just no longer searching in one place. They may start with Google, ask ChatGPT to compare their options, watch a YouTube video, look for examples on Instagram, read reviews, or open a map to find a nearby business. This does not mean your company needs to chase every new platform. It also does not mean SEO is dead. The best response to fragmented search is to strengthen the foundation you already have. Build a clear, credible website, answer the questions your customers ask, share real expertise, and ensure your business appears consistently on the platforms that matter to your audience. AEO, or Answer Engine Optimization , is part of that approach. It helps search engines and AI tools find and understand your answers, but it works best when it is built on strong SEO . Why Are Customers Searching in So Many Different Places? Customers are searching in more places because they now have more ways to find the type of information they want. Every Monday during our BlinkJar staff meeting, each person brings an industry update to discuss. One recent conversation about artificial intelligence and its impact on search reminded me of what happened to television. Jared, my husband and BlinkJar’s founder , spent years working in television. At one time, a few broadcast networks held most of the audience. Then cable created more choices. Streaming services, YouTube, social video, and on-demand programming divided attention even further. Television did not disappear. People gained more ways to watch. Search is moving in the same direction. A prospective customer may search Google for a service, ask an AI assistant to explain the differences between providers, watch a video to see how something works, and read reviews before visiting a company’s website. The challenge is not that Google has stopped working. It is that businesses can no longer assume every customer will begin there. Does My Business Still Need SEO? Yes, your business absolutely needs SEO as it remains the foundation of being discovered online. Google continues to drive valuable, high-intent traffic for businesses. A strong website also gives AI tools, maps, social platforms, and prospective customers a reliable place to learn who you are and what you offer. Your website needs clear service pages, useful location information, simple navigation, relevant internal links, and a sound technical structure. Search engines must be able to crawl, index, and understand your pages. Traditional SEO is not being replaced. It is supporting a larger discovery ecosystem. Think of your website as your company’s home base. Social media, maps, reviews, search engines, and AI tools may help customers find you, but your website is where you control the complete story.
Kingsley Working
By Kingsley Lavender July 20, 2026
Kingsley Lavender shares what he learned as a marketing intern at BlinkJar Media, including SEO, website updates, content marketing, and real-world agency experience.